Evidence-Based Faith
Peter's address to Cornelius about Jesus had none of the feel-good sentiments of some modern preaching. It was not designed to excite emotions by showing how trusting Jesus can make for a happier life. It was a succession of facts; historical evidence of the life, death, resurrection and future rule of Jesus Christ. The presentation was raw evidence from the mouth of an eye-witness (2 Peter 1:16).
The message focussed on the circumstances and consequences of Christ's death. 'They killed Him' (referring to the Jews) was an interesting expression considering that the Roman soldiers carried out the execution, overseen by a centurion … and Cornelius was a Roman centurion. What Peter meant was that without the hatred of the religious leaders, no charge would have been brought to Pilate. But whatever the worst which religion could do, God vindicated His Son in resurrection.
The risen Christ was not a public spectacle, as was His crucifixion. God chose the apostles to be eye-witnesses as men who saw, talked, ate and drank with Jesus after the resurrection. They were so convinced that He is the Passover lamb whose blood atones for sin and allows God to forgive sinners, that all were willing to suffer extreme persecution (most died violently). Their preaching was very potent: through Jesus you can be forgiven, but if you cannot believe in Him as your Lord then you will face Him without any defence, as your Judge.
Gospel preaching is not shaped by what people want to hear, but by what God wants them to hear. The key is a challenge: to believe that the blood-sacrifice of Jesus enables people, who admit they are sinners, to be forgiven. Without that essential ingredient there is no good news. It is true that such faith brings joy and peace, but suggesting that ‘people will feel better if they come to church’ is not the gospel. Gospel communication urges us to submit to God's assessment of ourselves as helpless sinners, and dare to trust that only the blood of Jesus Christ can bring God's forgiveness. That was the apostles' doctrine borne out of observed evidence (Acts 2:36-38). There is no other gospel known to the apostles (1 Corinthians 2:1-5), and no other gospel to share with friends and colleagues today.